The TurboTax vs TaxACT decision

Our last W-2 finally arrived yesterday, so I plunged right into doing the taxes. Much banging around online turned up no good reviews of the online tax software, grrr. I didn't even find many current reviews of the boxed versions, which surprised me. Isn't this a gimmie for every personal-finance beat writer at any publication of size? PC magazine had one of the only comprehensive bake-offs I could find.

I usually go with TaxACT, but I swore to look elsewhere after running into some minor hassles last year. One look at the prices of "elsewhere" nearly sent me running back. My Amex offered me a 25% discount on the federal-return cost with TurboTax ... but the savings that translates to is actually pretty small, especially since the more-expensive state return isn't discounted. Even with the discount, the total cost for TurboTax online for me will be about $48 -- versus $16 for TaxACT. Ow.

Still .... TaxACT was annoying me, and I'd never tried anything else. The reviewers all swear by TurboTax. Solely for the experience of taking the Cadillac out for a test drive, I decided to shell out and try it. (And hey, blog fodder.)

The interface was indeed a little smoother -- but I'm not sure the end result was any different. I didn't turn up any exciting new deductions I wouldn't have otherwise known about. Plus, TurboTax still had one of the more annoying features that irked me with TaxACT: if you need to go back and revisit something out of order, it's easy to get lost. While working on my state return, I clicked back to the federal return to check out a previously entered amount. That lost my place in the state return workflow, and I couldn't get back -- I had to click through all the fields I'd already entered, costing me an extra 20 minutes of work. Grr.

So, next year, I'll probably save the money and return to TaxACT.

For those allergic to paying full price for tax software, various deals abound. TurboTax has a 15% off deal to anyone paying with a Visa, Amex, MasterCard or Discover. Your financial services providers may have their own deals. My friend Fahmi reports that Fidelity offers TurboTax free to its customers, and PC World is making TaxACT free to subscribers. State Farm also offers TurboTax free for customers.

Meanwhile, if you have an adjusted gross income of $52,000 or less, you qualify for FreeFile -- a program 70 percent of taxpayers are supposedly eligible for. FreeFile deals have all kinds of odd qualification standards, but the IRS helpfully offers a wizard to guide you to an eligible program.

More from the tax trenches tomorrow ....